PROVA.

Methods by Prova

These are the documents in which Prova sets out its methods: standards, articles, method notes, and guides, and one guide from each collection in the library as it is written. Each one is free to read on the page and to download as a PDF, without an account.

Standards

The tests Prova applies to a claim, an evaluation plan, and a statement that work is independent.

The Honesty Layer Rubric

How to review a claim against its evidence.

Read the standard →PDF

The Risk Taxonomy of Evaluation Failure

How to identify evaluation risks before commitment.

Read the standard →PDF

Can We Call It Independent?

How to judge an independence claim about evaluation work that is under way or finished.

Read the standard →PDF

Articles

Arguments about what one kind of evidence can show, each worked through an example.

A Systematic Review Is a Study

What existing studies can contribute before new data is commissioned, and why differences between them are worth investigating.

Read the article →PDF

The Trial Tested the Offer

What a randomized trial of an offer estimates when not everyone offered takes part.

Read the article →PDF

The Bureaucracy Is Part of the Treatment

Why a causal question becomes clearer when it names the decisions through which a policy or program operates.

Read the article →PDF

Human Review Has to Be Tested

How a brief can report a true number that misleads, and what a review has to check to catch it.

Read the article →PDF

The Evidence Deficit

What makes useful evidence difficult to obtain, and how to test whether AI-assisted work changes the constraint.

Read the article →PDF

Method notes

One method problem each, and what to do about it.

The Missing Column

A rise after a program shows change. Estimating how much the program caused needs a credible comparison.

Read the note →PDF

Find the Comparison Already Inside the Work

Where to look for moments when similar people or sites received different access, and what to keep so the comparison can be assessed.

Read the note →PDF

Who Holds Methodological Authority?

How to allocate methodological authority before the work begins, and keep a record of material choices and of dissent.

Read the note →PDF

Why Do People Disappear From the Record?

How to investigate the conditions around refusal and missing records before narrowing a claim or collecting more.

Read the note →PDF

Guides

Longer guides that take a team through one recurring decision about evidence.

Why the Right Grade Depends on the Decision

How to assess evidence for its fitness for a use, without a universal ranking of methods.

Read the guide →PDF

Would Knowing Change the Decision?

A practical guide to giving an evidence request a useful purpose.

Read the guide →PDF

How Much Evidence Is Enough?

How to compare action, inquiry, delay, and staged commitment for one real choice.

Read the guide →PDF

A guide from each collection

Each collection in the Prova Library offers one of its guides free. A collection's guide is added here when it is written.

Preparing a Funding Renewal Case

What Can We Responsibly Say?

A practical guide to explaining results with their important limits.

Read the guide →PDF

Guides from the other collections will be added here as they are written.

Filled-in forms

A team works a collection's forms in the Prova app, one question at a time, with guidance beside each question. Forms filled in for a worked case will be shown here, read-only, each with a link to work it in the app. None is published yet.

Collections for communities

These collections are for residents and community groups. Every document in them is free to read.