Evidence architecture

The report is not the system.

A judgment is produced by a compound architecture of checks, relationships, conflicts, and gates. What follows is a composite of that work. It is here so you can see the depth. It is not a map of the instruments themselves.

From a live decision to a usable answer — and back

Choose a step in the path. The field underneath shows the kinds of work that bear on it.

QuestionJudgment
Composite field beneath the working pathUnnamed marks for checks, relationships, unresolved gaps, and human gates. Selecting a step in the path illuminates the marks that bear on it.CheckCheckRelationshipCheckUnresolved gapCheckCheckRelationshipCheckUnresolved gapCheckCheckRelationshipCheckUnresolved gapCheckCheckRelationshipRelationshipCheckRelationshipUnresolved gapCheckRelationshipCheckRelationshipUnresolved gapCheckRelationshipCheckRelationshipUnresolved gapCheckRelationshipCheckRelationshipUnresolved gapCheckCheckCheckRelationshipUnresolved gapHuman gateCheckCheckRelationshipUnresolved gapHuman gateCheckCheckRelationshipUnresolved gapHuman gateCheckCheckRelationshipUnresolved gapUnresolved gapCheckUnresolved gapRelationshipHuman gateUnresolved gapCheckUnresolved gapRelationshipHuman gateUnresolved gapCheckUnresolved gapRelationshipHuman gateUnresolved gapCheckHuman gateUnresolved gapHuman gateCheckRelationshipHuman gateUnresolved gapHuman gateCheckRelationshipHuman gateUnresolved gapHuman gateCheckRelationshipHuman gate

Check

Relationship

Unresolved gap

Human gate

22 marks in this composite bear on claims.

  • The sentence cannot exceed the record.
  • A named person owns the conclusion.
  • Limits stay visible. They are not averaged away.

Permanent tensions — managed, not resolved

  • What the record can supportWhat the decision wants said
  • Care in the checkBurden of collecting more
  • Using what operations already generateMeasuring independently enough to be believed

Each mark is a kind of check, relationship, gap, or gate. The working system contains more than this composite can show, and is not depicted here.

What this is for

See the depth. Then use a sentence that can survive it.

The architecture exists so a reader can tell the difference between a generated evaluation document and a judgment produced by inspectable work. A stronger architecture does not automatically produce a stronger claim.